Just to be clear it wasn't the CPU installation tool that messed it up it was the plastic cover (that I guess is similar? I don't know I never even opened the CPU installation tool) that the motherboard comes shipped with.
The only pros of this is I went ahead and upgraded to a z270 board which doesn't have a lot of the bloat that the Maximus VIII had (sata express, ps2 ports) and the new board has dual m.2 slots. But still, if I was going to upgrade anything it would not have been my motherboard and definitely not after only a year.