cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Why I Returned My G752VS OC Edition

cuniac
Level 7
I recently bought the G752VS-XB72K. After having it for less than 1 week, I decided to return it. I wanted to post my experience with this laptop so that it may help others with their purchasing decision. I wrote this in more or less of a story format so you can tell my train of thought during all of this.

I purchased the G751JY last black Friday. I loved this laptop. Yes it kind of big and heavy, but I take it everywhere with me and it is a power house. I heard earlier this month that NVidia was going to release their 10 Series for laptops soon and that it may not be an "m" chip, but a full desktop chip. To say the least this sparked my interest. Then two weeks ago NVidia did the incredible. A desktop GPU in a mobile package, and their posted performance looked incredible. While my current laptop has a 980m, these chips were wildly faster and I knew I wanted one.

I went right to the ASUS website that Monday, but they had not posted and new builds yet but two days later there they are. They had updated their G752 line with a 1070. It was not the 1080 I was hoping to get, but their unit with a 1080 in it was $4,500 bucks. Being that ASUS had always had very competitive prices before, I assumed it was priced that way for a reason. The 1070 was crazy powerful as it is, and when I saw an add on the ASUS home page for the G752VS OC Edition I was sold. Three days later, I had my new laptop.

I got my laptop just before I went to bed, so I just placed the box aside for when I woke up for work. When I woke up, I opened the box, to see this new laptop. At first glance I thought, "this seems bigger", but maybe it was just the silver color making it look bigger than my current black G751JY. Next I start to look at its coloring. Honestly I didn't really like it that much on the outside. I felt the copper and silver design was an odd choice, but once you open it the inside looks quite nice. I took my current G751JY out of my bag and went to place this one inside. It didn't fit! I had to more or less, shove and stretch the bag over this laptop just to get it in. My G751JY fit perfectly when some room to spare, so this was indeed bigger. If I loved the laptop, maybe getting a new bag is not a big deal.

When I got to my lunch time I fired it up, set things up and updated the NVidia drivers. I didn't see any updates even though I know there was one available, So I had to manually update it. Once that was done, I loaded 3dMark and run tests. The tests looks very good, getting very high scores. After they were done I went into Game Center to change it to the OC setting but to my surprise it already was. Apparently it is set to this by default. A little sad that I was not going to see higher scores I set it to Normal to see how much faster the OC was running. I was shocked to see that it ran faster when it was not over clocked. As you will see in the links at the bottom, it ran quite a bit faster most of the time not over clocked, really only running better in the less demanding title BioShock Infinite.

At this point I was kind of torn. Over Clocking made things worse but it was still very fast on standard so maybe it didn't matter. Next I tried the speakers, and was disappointed that I felt they sounded worse than my last laptop. I mostly used headphone anyway so maybe this was not going to be an issue. When I closed the lid I noticed it felt kind of strange. After opening and closing it a few times it felt kind of cheap and more plastic than my G751JY, This bothered me but maybe it wasn't as bad as I had thought.

Now I'm starting to feel very disappointed. Yes, this laptop ran fast and this is what mattered most but I'm also trying to look past the fact that its Bigger, Heavier, Doesn't fit in my bag, Doesn't look as nice, Doesn't over clock well, has poor sounding speakers and the lid feels cheap. As I'm looking on the ASUS website I notice something odd. A new page for the G752VS that says the display was 120Hz. My display is not 120Hz. The page I looked at originally shows that it was going to be 75hz, but now they had a new page saying they are going to, at some point, have the same model at 120Hz but its not the $2,500 unit I just bought?!? At this point I was really like "WTF Asus!" I was already thinking of sending it back when I saw the deciding factor, MSI released their new laptops.

I had never been an MSI fan, and I think the feel and layout of the ASUS keyboard is much better, But these specs Vs. what I just bought were ridiculous. Now yes, this laptop is $300 more than what I just bought, but this is what they will give you for that money. First and foremost was a 1080. A 1080! ASUS cheapest model with a 1080 is $4,500 and they are only asking $2,799??? The display on the MSI is 120Hz. Granted there is no G-Sync, but I don't think its going to matter with a 1080 and 120Hz. My current desktop as a 144hz and 780Ti and its been just fine. Keyboard is RGB. Sound is worlds better, It has one more audio port, one more USB 3.0 port, one more M.2 slot and looks better. The rest such as Ram, CPU, ect.. was all the same as the ASUS.

I have returned my unit, and am waiting for the MSI GT73VR to be released on 9/5. I will not know how I feel about it until I get it. I know they have a new cooling system too but no idea if its any better or worse than ASUS. There is no reason you have to pay $4,500 for a 1080. The problems I saw on their laptop are unforgiveable at this point. To still have poor audio, not realize that people think this laptop looks ugly, to charge so much and to have the build quality seem cheaper?!? I really hope I can come back to ASUS when I upgrade again in a year or two, but as it is right now I can no longer recommend ASUS laptops. Such a shame because they were so good, and well priced until now. Except the Audio, it has been bad for a while.

Benchmarks - https://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?87144-G752VS-Overclocking-to-Lower-Performance&p=604870#po...

ASUS Saying 120Hz - http://www.asus.com/ROG-Republic-Of-Gamers/ROG-G752VS/Features/?_ga=1.145225148.98725265.1471674595

ASUS Actual Available Models not 120Hz - http://www.asus.com/us/site/g-series/?_ga=1.145225148.98725265.1471674595


***Update 9/11/2016***
I left of last saying I was going to see how the new MSI laptop performs when it comes out. I have just received my GT73VR and wanted to go over that Vs. the G752VS briefly.

Like the G752VS the GT73VR has a G-Sync display, however the GT73VR is running at 120Hz vs 75Hz on the G752VS. 120Hz is not the same as say, going from 1080p to 4k but it adds a level of smoothness that is much welcomed. The GT73VR display is also using IPS and not TN panels Like the G752VS does giving you richer colors and better viewing angles.

I wont say to much about the GPU as its not fair to compare them too much since the G752VS has a 1070 and the GT73VR has a 1080, but needless to say it is nice jump as seen in the benchmark link I have updated.

Both of these Laptops say they can be overclock. Testing the G752VS in overclocked mode was very underwhelming as it has almost no gain and in some cases loss. However, with the GT73VR the overclocking shows noticeable gain across the board. I attribute this to better cooling on the MSI.

Lastly comes the temp and noise. The Temps were all very good, as the unit did not get any hotter underneath or on the keyboard similar to the G752VS or G751JY for that matter. The noise on the other hand was a bit louder than the G752VS. At max fan speed it was probably 2.5x louder, sounding like a small desk fan on low setting. During most game play it was not that loud but it could get that high. With the better cooling and 1080 the noise is passable and understandable but may be a problem for some as its not the whisper quite fans of the G752 series.

Overall the MSI build just felt better and if you don't mind the fan noise, it makes a lot more sense as its has a lot more bang for your buck. Also the speakers sound good.

Side Note: After seeing the cooling issues when over clocking the G752VS and seeing the cooling on this MSI with the 1080 and OC CPU, I would be cautious of the G701VI. It so thin that I don't know how its going to handle cooling a 1080. Just FYI.
33,601 Views
25 REPLIES 25

Simao wrote:
Hi Cuniac. Can you just tell me two things? (...)
First, between the Asus G752VS and the Msi GT73Vr, wich have the better temps? In overclock mode, and during gaming, what is the temp of the CPU oon your new laptop?
Second, about the fan noise, wich of them is more silent? Please try gaming in your new laptop with the fans in auto mode.

Thanks


So I ran a stress test with both the CPU and GPU max at 100% on the GT73VR. The CPU never got above 80c, fans never had to go above 3500rpm and was quieter than the GPU fan. The GPU would go between 78c and 81c with the fans going between 3500 to 4000rpm. One time I got them to go a bit higher but I'm not sure what I did differently but I think I may have had a vent obstructed. fan speed was set to auto and in Turbo (OC) mode.

The G752VS got much hotter on the CPU going in the mid 90's, and the gpu was right around 80c. I'm sorry to say I didn't wright the the exact numbers when I ran on that computer. These temps are the reason I feel this computer didn't do well on OC mode as I believe the CPU would start to throttle itself. The over all fan noise on this machine was quieter.

Its really kind of a gain loss thing. The G752VS was more quiet but the OC is pointless. The unit is a little to big as it didn't fit in my alienware 17 bag, construction felt a little cheap and I personally don't like the design. Also only 75hz and has a 1070. As to where the GT73VR has all the specs you could want but runs a bit louder.

Simao
Level 7
Ok, thanks for the answer. Im thinking between this two models with the GTX 1070. On this time, the Asus is being sailing as "top model edition in my country", with a free mouse, backpack and headphones. Also, this version cames with a 120Hz screen and G sync, 512gb ssd in raid 0.
The Msi GT73VR it will be only available in the end of the month.
My concern is only about the fan noise and the temps. I dont will overclock to much. I only will run the cpu in 3.8 Ghz.
Some people and reviews says that the asus can handle this speed around 70-80 ºC, other says that overheat. The MSI, from that you say and other reviews seems be very cool. In your new laptop, the bad thing is the gpu fan run between 3500-4000 rpm, what is very loud.
The CPU fan runs on max at 3500 rpm is very good. My last laptop, the G752VY some times run around 3700rpm.
I like quiet laptops, but in the other time i dont want a throttle in the cpu, overheat with the cpu increase into 90ºC.
But, your laptop with a gtx 1070, as im looking for, should run cooler, and more quiet.

Simao wrote:
Ok, thanks for the answer. Im thinking between this two models with the GTX 1070. On this time, the Asus is being sailing as "top model edition in my country", with a free mouse, backpack and headphones. Also, this version cames with a 120Hz screen and G sync, 512gb ssd in raid 0.
The Msi GT73VR it will be only available in the end of the month.
My concern is only about the fan noise and the temps. I dont will overclock to much. I only will run the cpu in 3.8 Ghz.
Some people and reviews says that the asus can handle this speed around 70-80 ºC, other says that overheat. The MSI, from that you say and other reviews seems be very cool. In your new laptop, the bad thing is the gpu fan run between 3500-4000 rpm, what is very loud.
The CPU fan runs on max at 3500 rpm is very good. My last laptop, the G752VY some times run around 3700rpm.
I like quiet laptops, but in the other time i dont want a throttle in the cpu, overheat with the cpu increase into 90ºC.
But, your laptop with a gtx 1070, as im looking for, should run cooler, and more quiet.



The newer version is for me (G-Sync / 120Hz) i7-7700HQ + GTX 1070 8GB - and CPU max. temp. 95c degree what is unacceptable for me. Did somebody else experience a so tall temperature? GPU goes away yet, because 79c degree max. Crysis under 3. (CPU it 95c degree) otherwise good little machine, discounting this.

mehdi_moha
Level 8
@cuniac , I sent you a PM
its appreciated to answer me

thanks in advance

mehdi_moha
Level 8
@cuniac , I sent you a PM
its appreciated to answer me

thanks in advance

gallajos8606
Level 7
Motherboard an exchange happened by way of the service (again) and the max. CPU temp. 85c (the test ran on a weekend it RMA and was stable) on the other hand on the new sheet 304 BIOS there is a version (this cannot be downloaded official Asus laterally. It would be my problem only already, that the G-SYNC no , only the 120Hz (302 BIOS may be needs to lay then...)