cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

ASUS G750JY... a slap in the face to G751 owners?

Richdog
Level 7
I mean seriously, ASUS are bringing out a new version of an old and classic design with a 980M, that I am sure they are aware people prefer (otherwise logially why release an old design?) due to the sleek back design and white keyboard keys that are easier to see and read? Can they have any more contempt for their customers, ie: G51 owners? Absolutely bizarre. :confused:

Info here http://www.asus.com/Notebooks_Ultrabooks/G750JY/

So yeah, I am now really annoyed as I would have loved to buy a laptop with that design and the G751 specification...
53,943 Views
76 REPLIES 76

ldelczeg wrote:
...It is normal if you turn off one of the heat-generators you have to deal with less heat.


ldelczeg, not with Optimus on the G750's, the Intel iGPU is always routing video, always on, and always generating heat, even when the Nvidia GPU is doing the rendering.

That is the problem with Optimus, the Intel iGPU gets in the path for everything, cutting off all the Nvidia control of the display and continually adding heat to the CPU.

The G750's with Optimus benchmark 10c higher in CPU temperatures compared to the previous non-Optimus models - with the same CPU's. And all of those Optimus G750's had 1.28v/1.35v memory.

You may be able to live with Optimus, but it isn't adding any benefit, certainly not worth the drawbacks.

Here is an example of an Alienware laptop without Optimus, so that it can include a 120hz internal screen, I wish Asus would do this as well, actually a 144hz display would be nice 🙂

Alienware 17 with 120Hz 3D Display Has No Integrated Graphics or Optimus - GTX 780M i7-4800MQ Laptop
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJ3IRvCkllg

Hopefully Asus will continue to offer ROG laptops without Optimus at the high end, so we get the full benefit of the Nvidia GPU we are spending all that extra $1000's on.

If the G750JY comes with a way to disable Optimus, and that method routes video directly from the Nvidia card to the display - internal/external, it should be an awesome laptop.

what you wrote is essentially the same as i wrote earlier. When optimus is active the nvidia card rendering everything in a virtual screen name intel vga`s framebuffer or video memory. That is why intel vga is always on. But as i would like to notice for this rendering you can turn that video card down on performance as in that case the intel vga rendering complete pictures, same as watching a movie. As i know no one tried and in 1215n everything is fixed so i cant play with frequencies. I will check this in Clevo. But i have to check other other things as well. As i wrote settings are important. 1.28 v module is not the same as 1.35 v module as not the 1.5 v module. In every details i agree with you.

ldelczeg wrote:
... 1.28 v module is not the same as 1.35 v module as not the 1.5 v module. In every details i agree with you.


ldelczeg, it turns out the range of acceptable voltage for DDR3-L allows for as low as 1.28v, and Asus shipped some models with that memory, not cheap and hard to find outside of Asus, I know I looked 🙂

The 1.35v is the standard available, but if you can find the 1.28v it generates even less heat. JEDEC standard 1.35V(1.28V~1.45V)

44665

hmscott, i downclocked the iGPU in my Clevo, after that the laptop became whisper silent and less times starts the fan blowing. the change is that the maximum iGPU clock changed from 1300 to 800. Software-s under windows reports different clocks as i did the change in the bios of the laptop. The fan starts blowing around 60 degrees celsius.
Now is more times under it, when it is under the cooling is passive.
16x50Mhz=800 Mhz. HOwever i noticed i have 1.5 V memory modules so now i am looking for change them to 1.35 V one or 1.25 V one. If someone could point me to a pair of 1.25 V memory module 2x4gb or 2x8gb one would be nice.

ldelczeg wrote:
hmscott, i downclocked the iGPU in my Clevo, after that the laptop became whisper silent and less times starts the fan blowing. the change is that the maximum iGPU clock changed from 1300 to 800. Software-s under windows reports different clocks as i did the change in the bios of the laptop. The fan starts blowing around 60 degrees celsius.
Now is more times under it, when it is under the cooling is passive.
16x50Mhz=800 Mhz. HOwever i noticed i have 1.5 V memory modules so now i am looking for change them to 1.35 V one or 1.25 V one. If someone could point me to a pair of 1.25 V memory module 2x4gb or 2x8gb one would be nice.


ldelczeg, you have gone too far the other direction 🙂

The DDR3U spec is 1.25v, the DDR3L spec is JEDEC standard 1.35V (1.28V~1.45V)

And, now I find it was early CPU-Z versions that displayed the G750JH Hyundai parts as 1.28v, but has now been changed to read 1.35v.

I just verified by downloading the v1.64 zipped version of CPU-Z, it shows 1.28v, but the latest 1.70.0 shows 1.35v on the same G750JH with the same memory.

Here is my G750JH showing 1.28v part, and later as a 1.35v part:

44672

44673

And, here it is showing 1.28v right now using a downloaded 1.64 version of the zipped generic CPU-Z

44674

Same laptop, same parts 🙂

When you add memory keep the make/model the same, for highest compatibility. Using CPU-Z as above you can find the make/model.

Getting the same 8GB part was easy, ebay had lots of listings for memory pulls - pre-tested burned in memory - for less than new.

For those with 4GB memory that want to add 8GB SO-DIMM's to the user accessible SODIMM sockets, you find the make/model line specification sheet that shows all the parts in the same family, and order the 8GB sister part, that will be most compatible as well.

If you want to get fancy, and not spend too much more memory, you can replace all 4 SODIMM's with 2133mhz parts, and G.skill offers parts that run at full speed in the G750, and I assume the G751 - but no reports yet.

G750 Haswell Boards Support 2133MHz SODIMM's
http://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?47957-G750-Haswell-Boards-Support-2133MHz-SODIMM-s&p=406625...

For me it doesn't offer enough of a measurable improvement, let alone a change I would feel, to justify swapping 32GB of 1600mhz memory that is working great, and then go through all the trouble to pull apart my G750JH to get at the top SODIMM sockets. The G751 seems to be easier to disassemble, but I have only seen photo's, noone has posted a disassembly video yet.

If you find DDR3U 1.25v memory and want to try it, make sure you can return it, it would be fun to see if it works and causes a drop in CPU temperature - and if it is stable, After all it is only .03v outside JEDEC DDR3L spec 🙂

Kingston has a brief description of DDR3U memory as compared to DDR3L, but there is no date (2011?) on the mention, and Kingston still isn't listing DDR3U memory, that I could find:

Ultra Low Voltage DDR3 (DDR3U)
http://www.kingston.com/us/community/articledetail/articleid/9?Article-Title=Ultra-Low-Voltage-DDR3-...

Hynix has developed DDR3U(Ultra Low Voltage) product with 44nm technology.
http://www.hynix.co.kr/mail/newsletter_2010_06/eng/sub01.html

Please come back and let us know what you got and how it works!

Probably optimal to post memory questions and answers here in the G751/G771/G551 sticky:

1.35V memory required in G751/G771/G551s (same as G750)
http://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?53752-1-35V-memory-required-in-G751-G771-G551s-%28same-as-G...

And for G750's in their sticky here:

Upgraders: 1.35V memory is required!
http://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?33744-Upgraders-1-35V-memory-is-required!

NitroX
Level 10
Hmm, apart from the Optimus, I really think that the G750 will still be more reliable than G751. I had one G751JY model that I have exchanged due to some backlight bleeding of the screen and a bad enter key. Now, this new models is a 10+ at aspect, but I get some crazy temps for the CPU :|... I don't really know what the issue is but hitting the 90's while playing AC Unity isn't quite recomforting. See the picture below
On the other model I could even OC the GPU with +135Mhz Core and a 5700Mhz Memory and would still have lower temps. I do hope that this is due to a bad pasting and that I will be able to ask the guys from the service to reapply the thermal paste on both GPU and CPU.



EDIT: I also have a problem now with overclocking the GPU. It seems that the OC is locked and I can't change either the Core or the Memory frequencies. I hope this is just due to the new Nvidia driver 347.09
EDIT2: Yes, the locked frequencies were due to the latest driver 347.09. Be careful if you update to this driver!

These are the results after a 2h 30mins gaming session:
4464844649

NitroX wrote:
...On the other model I could even OC the GPU with +135Mhz Core and a 5700Mhz Memory and would still have lower temps. I do hope that this is due to a bad pasting and that I will be able to ask the guys from the service to reapply the thermal paste on both GPU and CPU.

EDIT: I also have a problem now with overclocking the GPU. It seems that the OC is locked and I can't change either the Core or the Memory frequencies. I hope this is just due to the new Nvidia driver 347.09
EDIT2: Yes, the locked frequencies were due to the latest driver 347.09. Be careful if you update to this driver!


NitroX, are you running the 347.09 BETA or the 347.09 WHQL? Here is the WHQL if you haven't seen it:

http://www.guru3d.com/files-details/geforce-347-09-beta-driver-download.html

Asus GPU Tweak for Graphics Cards 2.7.1.8 is OC'ing fine for me with the 347.09 WHQL release, on a G750JH

44654

Asus GPU Tweak for Graphics Cards, currently at release V2.7.1.8 for the G750JW/JX/JH and G751JT/JY
http://support.asus.com/download.aspx?SLanguage=en&p=9&m=ASUS%20GPU%20Tweak%20for%20Graphics%20cards...

kanecvr
Level 7
NitroX - are you by any chance using 1.5v DDR3 memory? That causes the CPU overheat. I used to get 80-88C in far cry 4 with a set of corsair vengeance 1.5v memory. I've swapped them for a set of Micron DDR3L 1.35v and it does 75C max.

All this gripe about the red keyboard backlight - I LOVE IT. The white backlight on the G750 and my old Precision M6700 was extremely distracting and tiring. Altought, the ability to chose the color of the backlight would be preferable, it would alsi significantly increase the price of the machine - witch means I couldn't afford it. Asus was NOT my first choice. I would have gone for the MSI GT72 or a Clevo/Sager variant (because those have better cooling and an all important MXM slot to upgrade the video card later), but those were 500-700$ over budget. I got my G751 because it is fast and cheap - cheapest out of all machines equipped with a GTX 980m actually.

8GB of VRAM over the 980m's small 256bit bus is just silly. The GPU would need a 512bit to comfortably address that much video memory. More VRAM doesn't mean a faster video card. I tough this was common knowledge already. I did a review a few years back penning the 1Gb version of the GTX 460 against the 2GB version of the same card. The 1GB version wa 2-4% faster. More ram is only usable in games with large uncompressed textures - witch is very few. But still - if you have a small memory bus, the game is still going to run like crap.

Cooling system is just a mediocre on both the G750 and G751 variants. The 751 has larger heatsinks and shorter heatpipes witch should equal better cooling performance, but ASUS didn't cut out air holes at the bottom of the machine so it loses 20% of it's eficiency. I have a vid showing the G751 with no palmrest - it does 59-60C MAX in unigine heaven over a 30 minute run - versus 70-75C with palmrest on.

kanecvr wrote:
...Cooling system is just a mediocre on both the G750 and G751 variants. The 751 has larger heatsinks and shorter heatpipes witch should equal better cooling performance, but ASUS didn't cut out air holes at the bottom of the machine so it loses 20% of it's eficiency. I have a vid showing the G751 with no palmrest - it does 59-60C MAX in unigine heaven over a 30 minute run - versus 70-75C with palmrest on.


kanecvr, actually the G750 series has a better cooling system, as we have found by benchmarking / stress testing both the G751 and the G750.

The G751JY has a combined heat transfer plate between the CPU and GPU heatpipes, and under heavy CPU/GPU load it can thermal throttle the CPU - this is due to the smaller cooling system being combined into 1 such that the heat from both CPU/GPU mix and drive up the heat on both.

The G750 has 2 classes of cooling. the G750JW/JX//JM/JS have smaller heatsinks / fans, and the JH/JZ/JY having the largest heatsinks, heat pipes, and fans. Both systems are independent for CPU and GPU, with no heat transfer connection between them. This helps keep both cool under simultaneous load.

Here are some images, first the G751JM, then the G751JY, and then the G750JX and G750JZ

G751JM
44661

G751JY
44660

G750JX
44658

G750JZ
44659

I wouldn't classify either the G751 or G750 cooling systems as mediocre, but the G750 - especially the JY/JZ/JH are quite beefy, and more than adequate 🙂

@hmscott: I've used both the BETA and the WHQL versions. Both left me with a locked Core clock and Memory Clock. The 344.75 WHQL version still works fine. I'll stick with it for the moment.

@Kanecvr: I have only a single 8GB card which came preinstalled with the laptop. I don't know if it is a 1.35v or 1.5v because Aida64 doesn't seem to give me this information (See the pic below). I'm truly disappointed with G751's cooling... it's not that I'm asking too much, but the G75 I previously had was never hitting 85C even with an OC'ed GPU. This one is good for baking eggs with normal clocks while gaming.... I know that the fans are working, and the copper heatsink could do better but the heat is just not evacuated as fast as it should be. I also think that the pasting job isn't that great since the last model I had was hitting better temps (like -5/6 C compared to the current one).
Even if changing the DRAM would improve the cooling, I can't do that since I don't have another DRAM module and I also don't want to void the warranty . I'm thinking of buying a coolpad but this is just freaking lame when you talk about a 4kg machine that isn't capable of cooling itself... The cooling capacity was one of my most important criteria when I've chosen this laptop, because the G75VW I had was damn COOL.
EDIT2: @Kavecvr: I found out from CPU-Z that the Samsung 8GB module that I have is indeed 1.35v. So the voltage isn't the problem.

EDIT: @ Hmscott: I have seen these pics in another topic and it made me think at something. If the heatpipes of the CPU and GPU are combined, then why is the CPU constantly 10C hotter than the GPU? From my knowledge, the heat transfer usually has the direction (Hotter--->Colder), this means that a part of the heat generated by the CPU should be driven to the GPU. But for this model is the other way arround. If I OC the GPU then the CPU would also run hotter O_o... Where's the freaking logic in their cooling system?
44662