the adg1 are 100 buck more than the sennys, and their reviews (3.8 on amazon) are worse than the sennys (4.5 amazon). I think most of the complaints are about the wing design thou and the HOLD to mute button for the mic. People didn't like the non braided cord also i guess. On one good review about the adg1 and the game one said the where the same quality if u got a inline amplifier. The ADG1 are a little cheaper on newegg but they don't have a page for them anymore? discontinued maybe? The ADG1 are the about the same price as Beyerdynamic MMX300 right now and if i was going to spend close to 300 buck i would just get the beyers and get a in line amp.
i was suprized to see the ADG1, and the beyers not above 4 stars. I know they are both great companies with above average products. At any rate i dont think may people could tell the difference between them other than the in put ohm (volume)
The Audio-Technica ATH-PDG1 are more comparable to the sennys in price 170 us and features. Looks like they fixed most of the design problems. Toggle able mute, in line volume control both on the cord. it has lower input impedance also so should be louder then the sennys. Doesn't look like a braided cord thou. They look more like the sennys now the the old ADG1s. Those would be the ones i would say could beat out the sennys not enough reviews only 8 on amazon yet (4.1 stars). Once again the newegg link for them isn't working? Does newegg hate audio technica gaming headsets? The only link for a gaming headset that works is the AG1s.
Now I agree that reviews don't always get it right. Most of the bad reviews are about things people should have read about the product before buying it. the more reviews the closer the the real picture you get. Kinda like the jelly bean study.
http://www.diplomacy.edu/resources/books/reviews/wisdom-crowds-why-many-are-smarter-fewI'm guessing the audio tech and the beyer just didn't get enough reviews to get them past the bad ones.
PS dough69 did you get them yet???? if you didn't take a look at the ATH-PDG1 too as they might be louder and the same quility. still don't like the volume/mute on the cord and it not being braided.
a lot people in "audio" industry would say that audio tech are better quality then sennys for headphones thou. gaming headsets haven't been around long enough for the gaming community to compare really