not sure about board RMA yet, possible, but not sure about probability yet.
is there any chance, you could try a single card in PCIe_3 and see if it runs and can survive through restarts?
also which BIOSes have you tried? try as low as 704 or 1309, go through all of them if you have to, I'm pretty sure 680 SLI could be a BIOS issue actually and it was supposed to get fixed in one release (1408?), but someone complained that it didn't work right for him in next ones like 1501 or 1604.
.: R3C0NF1GUR3D :.ASUS MVE :: 3770K bench @ 5.2GHz (delidded) :: 2x4GB Mushkin 996990 @ 2400MHz CL10 @ 1.7V :: evga 670 2GB SLI @ 1280/7108 :: Mushkin Chronos 240GB SSD RAID0 (OS) :: WD RE4 2TB (storage) 2TB :: Hitachi Deskstar 5K300 2TB (backup USB3.0) :: ASUS VG248QE 24'' 144Hz monitor
My rig with pictures"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit." - Aristotle