Mine was same way sounded like pins were crushing.
so as I was pushing down on the lever I also put a light pressure on the other lever, so it didn't seem like I was pushing just one side of the cpu down.
not sure if it helped or is suggested, but no problems after power up.
Asus Rampage IV Black Edition / 4930K / Gskill Trident X 2800 4x4gb / Evga Titan sc/ SSD Samsung 840 pro 512gb / 2tb WD Black / Antec 1200 / Cosmos II / win 7 ultimate / G710 / Astro A50