Which two game titles combined would create the perfect game? [Battle #2]

[Bahz]

UPDATE:
Winners for Battle #2 announced:
http://rog.asus.com/articles/events/rog-forum-battleground-battle-2-winners-announced/

The second battle has arrived and it’s a battle for everyone! It’s a simple question that we all have probably have thought about at some point in time, here’s the question: Which two game titles combined would create the perfect game?

This battle begins on November 24th 2016 at 8:00pm (UTC+8) and ends on December 8th 2016 at 8:00pm (UTC+8).

The only limitation is that you can only include “two” game titles and not any more than that. No limitations on the genre of the game titles, so let your imaginations run wild! Simply post your two choices for the game titles and your explanation on why these two titles would make the perfect game.

Discuss and debate with others to earn additional entries for the grand prize draw!

See prizes and complete rules below:

Biweekly battle topic prizes

1st Prize – ROG Goodies Box (filled with a ton of exclusive ROG swag)
2nd Prize – Mafia 3 Game Code (digital game code)
3rd Prize – Mafia 3 Game Code (digital game code)
4th Prize – Mafia 3 Game Code (digital game code)

Grand Prizes (draw will take place between January 5th 2017 – Janurary 11th 2017)


Rules

• Name two titles you think would create the perfect game and also your explanation on why you think so. Only entries meeting this criteria will be counted as a qualified entry for the biweekly prize draw or grand prize draw
  
• Limit one entry per person for the biweekly prize draw but no limit for additional entries for the grand prize draw
  
• Additional qualified replies/comments will earn you additional entries for the grand prize draw. All additional qualified replies/comments on this thread or the other 3 battle topic threads will be accepted as additional entries up until January 4th 2017
  
• Qualified replies/comments must have substance and not 1-2 word replies and are helpful in carrying forward the discussion. The eligibility of each reply/comment will be determined by our ROG forum admins.
  
• Winners will be announced on the ROG website 3 days after the conclusion of the battle (December 11th 2016).
  

For complete rules for this campaign, please visit the official campaign thread:
https://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?88630-ROG-Forum-Battleground-Community-Campaign-OFFICIAL-T...

[petar_popovac]

for 3 reasons:

1. the movement of the character(Why for the love of god does GTA V guy need 3 meters of space to turn around?), parkour, climbing on buildings...

2. Fight ...it would be great if Rockstar put these things

3. Connect the history and the present... these two worlds in one map, everything would be turned like in a movie Doctor Strange hahaha 😄

Would you ROGers add something else?



question for Bahz: Is it okay to post pictures with text. like this?

[Bahz]

petar_popovac wrote:
for 3 reasons:

1. the movement of the character(Why for the love of god does GTA V guy need 3 meters of space to turn around?), parkour, climbing on buildings...

2. Fight ...it would be great if Rockstar put these things

3. Connect the history and the present... these two worlds in one map, everything would be turned like in a movie Doctor Strange hahaha 😄

Would you ROGers add something else?



question for Bahz: Is it okay to post pictures with text. like this?

No problems at all, in fact it would be better to include pics 🙂

[MrGrozdek1993]

The world of BioShock (both city of Rapture and Columbia) mixed with scale, RPG elements and amazing quests from Witcher series 🙂

[SirMisAlot]

:confused:

[petar_popovac]

Imagine this football simulation, gameplay of PES and FIFA licenses, online stuff...

all faces would be real, all kits, football clubs, all tournaments would be licensed.



and finally it would be a perfect sport simulation. 😄 Would you add something else in this game??

[Omnisentient]

Edit: My actual entry for Battle #2 is on page 14.

If these two games ever gets combined, I think it would be a best seller. Saint's Row IV * and No Man's Sky.

Now, No Man's Sky lacks a lot of things: good graphics, structures or buildings, depiction of civilizations of other planets and galaxies, aliens or people, intelligent beings, advanced society and vehicles, and a good story. No Man's Sky's gameplay is quite boring too. However, the game offers exploration in a very vast universe and it already has a procedurally-generation system. The idea is really there, but the game failed to deliver the promises they made, the real experience of universe exploration.

Saint's Row 4 on the other hand offers a lot of good things. It has really good graphics, detailed structures and streets, interesting story line, tons of missions, very likeable characters, different types of vehicles. But the best thing about it is how they were able to depict civilizations and society well, both human's and Alien's. But Saint's Row lacked something, the game didn't have a huge setting. In fact, Saint's Row 3 and 4 even have a similar map.

So imagine if we combine those two games, those two formulas, all their pros. We will have a game where you can explore the universe, visit many planets. Where each planet will have things in it to depict its civilization, culture, it's tier on the Kardashev Scale. It could be a civilization same as ours in real life; It could be futuristic with tall buildings, dyson spheres, hover cars, intelligent beings, advanced military weaponry; It could be a bit uncivilized, with stone houses, dumb beings, huge creatures; It could also be very random, like off a parallel universe. It would be no surprise if there was a planet where all people are just happy and jolly, like that small simulation area in Saint's Row 4.

Having all of things would definitely make the player feel that they are experiencing universe exploration. It won't be just about finding what weird animals other planet has, it would be also about finding out what civilizations and cultures they have. The game would also not focus on mining minerals, it would have a story. Knowing Saint's Row 4 characters, the story would most likely be about conquering planets, galaxies, and the entire universe for fun. It would have tons of small missions on different planets.

The main character is also going to be fully customizable. You could make it look like you, have your voice, and you could make it carry any weapon imaginable in the universe. You will also have the freedom not just to name a planet and its creatures, you will also have the freedom to try and wipe out an entire planet's citizens and structures.

I think overall, this would be an insanely fun game. Although it would probably require a huge disk space, probably on terabytes.

* For those who are not familiar with Saint's Row IV, it's an open world game a bit similar to GTA games, except it has sci-fi involved.

[petar_popovac]

Omnisentient wrote:
If these two games ever gets combined, I think it would be a best seller. Saint's Row IV * and No Man's Sky.

Now, No Man's Sky lacks a lot of things: good graphics, structures, civilization, intelligent aliens, advanced society and vehicles, story. And its gameplay is quite boring. But No Man's Sky offers exploration in a very vast universe. The idea is really there, but too bad they failed to deliver.

Saint's Row 4 on the other hand offers a lot of good things. It has really good graphics, detailed structures and streets, interesting storyline, tons of missions, and very likeable characters. But the best thing about it is how they were able to depict civilizations and society well, both human's and Alien's.

So imagine if we combine those two formulas. A game where you can explore the universe, visit many planets. And those planets will have things in it to depict its civilization. It could be a civilization same as ours. It could be futuristic with tall buildings, dyson spheres, hover cars, intelligent beings. It could be a bit uncivilized, like with stone houses, less intelligent beings, huge creatures.

The game would also not focus on mining minerals, it would have a story. And knowing Saint's Row 4 characters, the story would most likely be about conquering planets, galaxies, and the entire universe for fun. It would have tons of small missions on different planets. The main character is going to be fully customizable. You would have custom appearance, voice, and could bear almost any weapon in the universe. Weapons that you could use to kill aliens, and you'd probably be hunted by an entire planet.

I think overall, this would be an insanely fun game. Although it would probably require a huge disk space, probably on terabytes.

* For those who are not familiar with Saint's Row IV, it's an open world game a bit similar to GTA games, except it has sci-fi involved.

Good idea. For me, the more content of Saint's Row IV in No Man's Sky it would be better... No Man's Sky gameplay is boring, with the content of Saint's Row game would be much, much more interesting 😄

[akao1111]

my pick would be Titanfall2 and Battlefield1, imagine if I can bring the titan to the world War 1 war zone, I could destroy enemies with ancient weapons in a mere second, that would be perfect for me, nightmare to others

[BeaverBeliever]

Far Cry 3 Blood Dragon + Borderlands 2

Imagine riding on a laz0r dinosaur throughout an 80's post apocalyptic pandora after a nuclear war for Eridium
with your cybercommando abilities and 5000000 different versions of that shotgun from terminator 2, except now it shoots lightning.
And ofcourse, coop.