Your ramping up and down when merely surfing is not normal. Something is amiss. I'm sure you're aware that with modern CPU's there is a relatively high frequency temp output variation, you'll see it on the graphs, Aida64 graphs for example, but that's normal. What you're describing is a lower frequency affect that impacts fan RPM.
I'm air cooling of course. Noctua NH-D15S and five Noctua PWM case fans. All controlled by my FanXpert fan curves.
Where is your CPU rad fan RPM/Temp curve? That's the important curve to see! Is the curve too steep, so that even a slight change in temp changes fan RPM? Did you try a flatter curve? If the CPU fan/Temp curve is flat enough there can't be sudden up and down RPM changes, just while surfing the net. Not unless your motherboard temp sensor is screwed up beyond belief.
Default fan curves are often less than effective and sometimes display the over sensitivity you mention, so change it
Your three attachments don't work.
My fans don't ramp up and down as you describe even under load Justin, They don't do it any time at all. That applies to my very old 17 920 system, my 3770K system my son now has and my new 6700K system. My 6700K CPU has not been delidded.
It may not be true for you when you have your CPU undervolted and underclocked. Any chip, delided or not will jump 40C at the drop of a hat when put under load.
Yes you are right, if you put a chip under load the temp will increase rapidly.
But that doesn't mean your fans have to. FanXpert includes the "Fan Spin up" and "Fan Spin Down" option. This can be set anywhere from zero seconds to around 204 seconds. It's designed to prevent any sudden increase in fan RPM. In addition, everything that can be set in FanXpert can also be set manually, by you, in the UEFI. So even if you don't like FanXpert, this can easily be configured.
Have you tried entering your UEFI and adjusting your fan spin up and down time??? It will stop your fans reacting instantly to temp changes. Should smooth things out.
Menial tasks like surfing the web and the fans would ramp up out of nowhere from 400 rpms to 2500 then back down again........repeatedly and had the same result with 3 6700Ks. Search the web and you will see this same scenario literally thousands of times across every enthusiast forum out there. How to fix it? Use a different reference that doesn't move so drastically.
Justin, menial tasks like surfing should NOT cause your CPU load and thus temp and thus fan RPM to suddenly jump up and down. CPU load doing those things shouldn't cause a load of sufficient intensity and duration to cause fan RPM to spike. If that's happening to you something is wrong. I suspect your fan curve is wrong with no spin up or down delay set.
I've not had issues like that with ANY system I've built Justin, and that must be about 9 systems now over the years, built for me, my friends and family. I can surf the web all day, watch YouTube videos, talk to you on the forum, whatever... and my fans stay at almost a constant RPM, maybe one or two RPM variation. Under load, the fans ramp up to whatever the RPM is that my fan curve deems is appropriate and they stay there.
Can you give me some links to this phenomenon that you say happens literally thousands of times? I'm interested reading about it.
and I would ask anyone who claimed otherwise to post up a video showing their CPU temps and fan speeds as Id have to see it to believe it.
Believe it Justin... I don't tell lies, I have no motive to.
The variable between our two systems of course is I'm on air and you water.
There is one occasion I've seen this.... when FanXpert occasionally chooses to ignore my fan curve. Then there is a minor ramping up and down. But as I say...
it's because the fan curve is wrong!