Yip that is a valid point and just higlights the gulf in value between the touted benchmark results in reviews or on the box and real world. I like your way of thinking more. You have actually nailed what is the best actual benchmark or test for a graphic card, play the game. And play the game at the settings you want to play on.
Nothing provides a more accurate representation of your cards performance than when you use it for the purposes you bought it. And in all honesty all a benchmark shows is what your card can do running that application. If a person needs to compare it against others scores to be validated then all good. But no matter what your benchmark score is you are still going to get the same performance in game consistent with that card and the overclock you set. Once you start lowering performance to gain FPS you do defeat the purpose I agree.
For many many folks the purpose is benching. And that means using all the tweaks (legal) that are available. And yes that means lowering the level of detail if you like to get more score. The purpose for benchers is to get the highest score not have a pretty picture.
Both worlds are fun, and both are valid for the respective users.
🙂
To help us help you - please provide as much information about your system and the problem as possible.