Full Disclosure, this turned into TL;DR
shilent wrote:
I'm having a similar problem. But instead of fans stuck on max speed, mine get stuck at random times. Sometimes the fans stay at minimum speeds, sometimes at max, sometimes somewhere in between.
It rarely happens, but worried that I may damage components from heat if I don't catch it in time. For example, I was playing a game, but the fans speeds did not ramp up. Luckily I have an external display monitoring my water temps and I saw it at 47C.
I thought maybe it was monitoring software like someone mentioned, so I stopped using HWinfo. But just now it happened again after running 3D Mark. My fans went up to about 90% and stuck there. The only software running at the time was Steam, 3D Mark, and MSI Afterburner.
I'm using Chassis2 and Chassis 3 headers, and when this happens, both are affected.
So It appears my issue is extremely close to yours!
I just posted a few days ago in the 1501 BIOS Thread about it, and was pointed here by an informed user. Just read through the thread. So the OP has/had a problem where his sensors Malfunctioned and then the problem happened. He also states his Fans Run To Max.
My problem is pretty much Identical to The Last Poster I am quoting. It seems to be completely random when my controller goes out. And when it does the fans get stuck on the speed they were at when the controller stops responding. I can't find any system events that lead me to the issue. I often don't even realize it right when it happens because I run my fans around 30 to 40 percent depending on where they are located, and don't start with an agressive curve until about 59C. So I only notice it right away when it happens while playing a game or running a bench mark, because the fans spin up to a very audible 80 percent, and then when the Temp comes down, my fans will stay up at 80 percent until a reboot. Although it usually happens just randomly when the Temp is sitting around Idle between 35 and 45c, so I might not notice until I see my temps climb and don't see or hear my fans responding.
Luckily I have incredibly good airflow in my case, so even with them spinning between 30 and 40 Percent, it seems to be enough to keep my Temps below 70 Tdie, even while running an Aida Stress Test, which actually surprised me, but I digress.
So I too thought this was a software thing. I have a Corsair H100i V2 and a Corsair rm1000i so I run CLink, which is some buggy ass software. I initially ran all of my fan headers off of my Corsair Link Commander Pro, so didn't notice issues at first with the Onboard Fan Controller. But because of the buggy nature of Link, It would crash and I would lose the ability to control my fans at least 2 or 3 times a session, so I completely Unistalled Corsair Link, and plugged in all of my fans to the Motherboard.
I have a 3 Monitor Setup and use only HWinfo to monitor temps on the third screen. Although I thought this might be an issue too, so I uninstalled that for a time being, and Aida64 to no avail. I remove all traces of programs out of the registry when I uninstall a program so I am as certain as possible there is no trace left.
I also dual boot to a fresh Windows 7 Install (Instead Of my Win 10 Pro Daily Driver) and this has not had any Fan control or Monitor Software installed (Except HWinfo64) and the same damn thing happens.
I built my system when BIOS 1401 was new, and have flashed every BIOS and Beta BIOS since all the way up to 1501 which is what I am on now. I use all my headers except the Water Header, My Pump Is plugged into the AIO Header, And All PWM Fans are spread across the remaining CPU AND Chassis Headers. I have tried setting Manual Curves in Q Control and using the presets, nothing seems to fix it.
Also as an Experiment I installed AI Suite and used Fan Xpert to control the fans, and the same damn THING HAPPENS!!! At some point, sometimes minutes, sometimes hours into a boot, My fans get stuck at a point on the curve and no longer change. I really am at a loss.
Not sure what else I can add to help, but I have tried most things I can think of and still can't figure out why the hell this is happening.
Any Suggestions would be appreciated. For now I just boot off the machine when not in use. O also, Hibernation and Sleep are both Disabled.
Good Luck everyone, hopefully ASUS Jumps on this for us, I only use ASUS motherboards because I have always loved the Quality. This is the first one to disappoint, and it sucks because its a lovely board, but this problem is just something that I consider too important not to have. I am about to try another Fan Controller, this time from NZXT to see if their software is better than Corsairs Buggy Suite, and is actually reliable. Something has to work...
P.S. I Miss SpeedFan...