cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Rog x570 crosshair hero viii

SCANNERMAN
Level 7
So I bit the bullet and ordered it. It should be here in two days. Since I'm not familiar with building the newer AMD stuff I decided to adopt the humble novice approach and start asking for advice. It has been an interesting experience to say the least. Then I remembered that I'm already an ROG member even though I still don't own my own gaming PC. (I have a very nice work station.) But, I digress. . .

Something is nagging me. Gamers are telling me not to over populate the DIMMS on my board. I'm accustomed to using 128 GB of RAM but I'm being advised to use 32 at the most in my gaming build. In addition to this I am told that the board I purchased uses daisy chain topology and therefore I should only use the first to DIMMS and not bother with the second. Little annoys me more than empty DIMM slots.

Then there is the matter of what RAM is best to buy for the system board. OMGG... This has got to be the most harrowing of all PC discussions I've had in years. So I will simplify: Since I'm being told that if all I'm going to do is game with the HERO (isn't that what it was made for?) that anything above a Ryzen 3700x is a waste. Fine. I'll save some coin and ditch the 3900x idea. But I'm still undecided as to what is the best RAM to use on this motherboard.

Does anyone here own an X570 HERO VIII with a fully populated system board? If so, what sort of RAM do you recommend for this and what can I do to avoid making any silly mistakes on this platform. I'm coming from a highly dominated Intel background so I'm assuming nothing here. Thanks in advance.
6,642 Views
7 REPLIES 7

RedSector73
Level 12
SCANNERMAN wrote:
Gamers are telling me not to over populate the DIMMS on my board. I'm accustomed to using 128 GB of RAM but I'm being advised to use 32 at the most in my gaming build. In addition to this I am told that the board I purchased uses daisy chain topology and therefore I should only use the first to DIMMS and not bother with the second. Little annoys me more than empty DIMM slots.

Then there is the matter of what RAM is best to buy for the system board. OMGG... This has got to be the most harrowing of all PC discussions I've had in years.


RAM:-
Daisy Chain is the technology, and there is nothing wrong with that. The Ryzen 3000 series has a extremely capable memory controller (much better than Ryzen 1 & 2), you can have 4 x DIMM, with the Max. 128GB and something that only Intel server chips / boards have, ECC ram.
83166

What you can have and what you need is two different things. If your serious as a gamer, than you really don't need 128gb or ECC Ram regardless of Intel or AMD system and most cases this is total waste of money.

For gaming,
Ideally, you need 16gb and 32gb is overkill. Dual RAM on one channel will get the best results. The issue here is how big is your fuel tank (RAM) for the engine (CPU). Is bigger best ? What is best, is the two, just the right size to get you A-B without needing to go to the service station (M2 nvme drive or HDD or SSD) and fill up all the time. No game uses more than about 12gb at the moment and most video creation work needs more than 16gb and less than 32gb. If you have dual roles in mind than go 32gb but it gets harder to get extreme speed with the extra weight of the fuel tanks (RAM), 16gb generally speaking is the right size and get best speed when teamed up with your engine (CPU).

*DDR4@3200 is the minimum speed you should consider.
*DDR4@3600 is optimal speed in most games.
*DDR4@3800 is optimal speed in benchmarks and applications.
DDR4@4133 is the highest I have tested.
DDR4@4800 is the highest supported speed by the motherboard.



Generally speaking, manufacturer wise, Samsung B-die and Micron E-die have tightest timings at any set speed.

*Assumption made from my own testing Samsung b-die 2x8 using Ryzen Dram Calculator fast profiles, microcode 1.0.0.4(b), cpu auto clocks.




CPU:-
Right now 3900x is overkill for gaming, just like most sport cars engines are. It's like saying no point having 800hp engine because in certain cimstances the wheels spin and cant get all the speed transferred to the wheels without slippage. So here have this Scooter, 50hp it will get you A-B without any worries, or you can have this sporty 500hp car. They all get you A-B, but when you need horsepower or to be first, which is, your cars engine ?
I rather have future CPU with more go in reserve (if I need it) than select 50 or 500HP engine. After all, your engine, in the future, maybe driving a shiny new GPU (the transmission of the car) which can now use 800hp without spinning the wheels or right now according to 3dmark 99% of the systems are slower than mine, oh no my gaming future looks brighter than I need.

83167

Hopefully you can identify with the car analogy. I thought it might help. In any case you can always get more ram or bigger cpu at a latter date and you should buy what is within your budget or suits your needs. I don't regret having 3900x and I was very tempted to go 3600, 3700 & 3800 but in the end I glad I got the 3900x and you have 3950x out end of this month which is 16 core / 32 thread monster (that might be, ok you can fit jet engine in a car but should we or might be tomorrow's normal sports car ?).

If you want crystal ball look, then I would look to what is going into the new xbox and playstation. This will tell you what you need to have for your computer into the future of gaming on PC's. It also looks very AMD.


Hope you find this of help.

I do appreciate the analogy and much of what you shared so far I already knew. Validation is always a good thing. But you didn't quite answer what I was really getting to. There is this matter of RAM. What would be the best RAM and how can I efficiently use all the DIMM slots in the board without going overboard? I'm convinced that 3900x would be overkill if all I intend to do is use this build for gaming. That is precisely what I purchased the ASUS x570 HERO VIII for: Gaming. Since I already have a very nice work station with all the memory and storage I need for non-gaming related activity I am inclined to agree with those who have informed me that the 3900x is indeed overkill. Still, I would feel much more comfortable with 32 GB of RAM @ 4X8 if this wouldn't be too much of a drop in gaming efficiency. Am I asking for too much or am I being unrealistic? I seriously don't know. I was hoping someone with the same system board and more experience with AMD builds than I have might be able to provide the answers to my questions. I do not know what RAM to purchase and how much of it I should get. Thank you for your advice.

SCANNERMAN
Level 7
WOW. Not much visible difference huh? Thanks again. what would you recommend for a 4x8 configuration? What make and manufacture?

There is more stability and better overclocking performance of your ram with two sticks instead of four. Ryzen has traditionally had problems with four sticks. Getting two 16gb sticks would allow you more room later when bios and drivers are much more mature, and it will run better overall. I recommend GSKill, as that is what I have had the best luck with, over many years. if you have a X570 board, get 3600mhz. The CH VIII should do very well with this setup.
CoolerMaster Maker 5T - ASUS CROSSHAIR VIII EXTREME - 65-inch UHD 4k SAMSUNG Q8FN - AMD Ryzen 9 5900X - NZXT Kraken X72 - 10 SIRIUS LOOP/NZXT RGB Case Fans W/ HUE+ - Gigabyte AORUS 1080 TI EXTREME - 64GB GSkill TRIDENTZ NEO 3600Mhz DDR4 - 3X XPG GAMMIX S70 2TB NVMe SSD'S- 2X CORSAIR FORCE MP600 NVMe SSD'S - WD BLUE 8TB HDD - Logitech wireless KRAFT advanced keyboard - Logitech M570 wireless trackball - Dual booting WIN 11

AQUASTEVAE wrote:
There is more stability and better overclocking performance of your ram with two sticks instead of four. Ryzen has traditionally had problems with four sticks. Getting two 16gb sticks would allow you more room later when bios and drivers are much more mature, and it will run better overall. I recommend GSKill, as that is what I have had the best luck with, over many years. if you have a X570 board, get 3600mhz. The CH VIII should do very well with this setup.


While historically correct Ryzen 1 & 2. I've not seen anything suggesting Ryzen 3000 series have issue with four, it has new memory controller which is considerably better than previous generations of which I also own 1800x & 2700x. Anyway I agree g.skill (low latency stuff is possibly samsung b-die) or Ballistix (typically micron e-die with a few samsung b-die) on QVL list for configuration is best way to go.

SCANNERMAN wrote:
WOW. Not much visible difference huh? Thanks again. what would you recommend for a 4x8 configuration? What make and manufacture?


I think the video answered the question. My experience would tell me to agree with the poster above, however the information and posts I've seen tell me a different story, that 4x8 works and is good. 32gb total is more than enough for gaming. I can't see a time before you retire the whole board (even with upgraded cpu's) that you would need more. Fairly sure gamers nexus or buildzoid have covered this topic as well, just could not remember the videos to link them or bothered enough to look for it again.


https://www.asus.com/au/Motherboards/ROG-Crosshair-VIII-Hero-WI-FI/HelpDesk_QVL/

IDC about the brands much, it's the manufacturer of the ram that matters, so if you want Samsung b-die this tool in advanced is amazing
https://benzhaomin.github.io/bdiefinder/

flyinion
Level 12
Also, keep in mind you could go with something like Corsair's Vengeance series if you're looking for RGB RAM. They sell dummy sticks that match that only pull power from the extra two slots to power and control the RGB but there's no RAM on them to cause any conflict with the other sticks (supposedly, though I'm sure the power draw must have some effect but that's just my uneducated guess there). DDR4-3600 is considered the sweet spot for Zen 2 and prices on those are really coming down. When GSkill released their Trident Z Neo series for Zen 2 the 3600 kits were cheaper than their older Trident Z kits I'd been looking at just a few weeks before that at the same speeds and timings. I'm currently running this kit https://www.newegg.com/g-skill-32gb-288-pin-ddr4-sdram/p/N82E16820232867 at 16-20-20-36 with zero issue and stock voltages and those were just the "SAFE" timing from the DRAM calculator tool. I haven't even tried the "FAST" settings yet. They have a 4x8GB kit of it as well. Of course you can get faster timings out of the box if you want to pay more $$$. Also mine are Hynix CJR not the Samsung stuff unfortunately. The Samsung kit is about $290 right now.